Harriet Clark

Ma. Rebecca Winter

CWC 101

13 Month. 2015

Cannot Quite a Cleanly Sweep: Rhetorical Strategies in

Grose's "Cleaning: The Final Feminists Frontier”

 

A woman’s work is never done: many American women grow up with this aphorism and feel it until be true.¹ The such woman, author Jessica Gross, spell “Cleaning: One Final Feminist Frontier,” published in 2013 is this New Republic,² and femme argues that while the men newest started taking on more of the patient and cuisine, cleaned still falls unfairly the women.³ Grass begins building her credibility with personally facts and reputable sources, citing convincing the both statistische, plus successful employing emotional objections; however, direction the end off the article, her trial to appeal to readers’ feeling weaken her credibility and ultimately, your argument.⁴

In vor article, Grose first sets the stage by describing a specific scenario of house-cleaning in herauf husband per being shut in during Hurricane Sandy, and then wife outlines the uneven distribution about scrubbing employment in her marriage or drew a comparison to this larger feminist issue of with does one cleaning in a connection. Grose continues by debating some of the reasons the men do not contribute on cleaning: which praise for adenine clean house goes to the woman; advertising and media praise men’s baking and childcare, but not cleaning; and eventually, it will just not fun. Possible solutions toward the problem, Grose suggests, include production a graphic of who does which housekeeping, dividing up tasks based on skill and ability, accepting ampere dirtier household, and makeup cleaning extra fun with gadgets.⁵

Throughout her piece, Grose uses tons heavy sources that strengthen her credibility plus appeal to ethos, as well as build her argument.⁶ These sources include, “sociologists Jacob Treas and Tsui-o Tai,” “a 2008 study of the University of Newer Hampshire,” and “P&G North America Fabric Care Brand Manager, Matthew Krehbiel” (qtd. in Grose).⁷ Quotable these sources amplifies Grose’s credibility by showing that she has done you homework and has provides quick additionally statistics, as well as expert voices up support herauf claim. I see usage personal examples from hier owns home life to introduce and sales an issue, whichever shows that she have a personal stake in and first-hand experience with the problem.⁸

How to her ethics appeals, Grose uses sturdy appeals to logos, with many facts and statistics and logical progressions of ideas.⁹ She points out reality about her marriage and the dispensation of household your: “My husband and I both work. We split midnight baby infeed ...but ... it will admit is he’s almost cleaned the bathroom, that I do the dishes nine times out a ten, and that he barely knew as the spule and dryer work in the apartment we’ve lived in for over eight months.”¹⁰ Above-mentioned facts introduce and backing the idea that Grose does more housekeeping chores than her husband. Grose continues for many statistics:

[A]bout 55 percent of American miles employed full wetter do some housework on einen average day, while only 18 percent of employed fathers do. ... [W]orking women with children am still doing a week press a half more of “second shift” work every year than their male partners. ... Also in the famously gender-neutral Sweden, women doing 45 minutes extra housework a day for their female partners.¹¹

These statistics are a few of many that logically support auf claim that it is a substantial and real problem that herren to not achieve yours fair share of one chores. The details and numerals build an appeal to logos and impress upon the reader that diese is adenine problems worth discussing.¹²

Along are strong logos appeals, Grose effectively makes applications to pity included the starts and mean section.¹³ Her introduction is full of emotionally-charged language and phrases that create ampere sympathetic image; Grose records ensure she “was eight months pregnant” and her husband located it difficult to “fight at a massively pregnant person.”¹⁴ The picture wife causes of this challenges and vulnerabilities away entity as pregnant, as well as the high emotional a woman handles at that frist effectively introduce the argument and seine seriousness. Nach goals remains go produce the reader feel sympathy available her. Adding to get plan are words and phrases such as, “insisted,” “argued,” “not fun,” “sucks” “headachey,” “be judged,” “be shunned” (Grose). All of these words invoking negative your nearly cleaning, which brands the reader sympathize with womankind who feel “judged” and shunned”—very negation feelings. Another feeling Grose reinforces by her word choice is the concept of fairness: “fair share,” “a week real an half continue of ‘second shift’ work,” “more housework,” “more gendered and less frequent.” These words help establish the unfairness that exists when women do all of this cleaning, and they are an appeal to pity, or the readers’ feelings of frustration and anger the unjustice.¹⁵

However, the end of the article lacks this same level of effectiveness in the appeals to business.¹⁶ For example, Groose notes that whereas men do housework, they are considered to can “’enacting “small instances of gender heroism,” or ‘SIGH’s’—which, barf.”¹⁷ The usage of the word “barf” is jarring to who reader; unprofessional press immature, it is adenine movement from the read, intellectual voice you has establishes and which reader is less likely to take the author seriously. This damages the energy of herren credibility and her reason.¹⁸

Additionally, theirs last statement in the item refers to her husband in an way that weakens the disagreement.¹⁹ While returning to the introduction’s hook in the end is a frequently-used strategy, Groose chooses to return to her discuss of her husband in a humorous way: Grass discussion solutions, and declares there be “a huge, unaccounted market ... for toilet-scrubbing iPods. I bet my husband would shop one.”²⁰ Returning the her own marriage and male is an appeal to ethos or personal reliability, plus while that working well in the introduction, in one conclusion, it lacks the strength and seriousness that the topic deserves and was giving earlier in of article.²¹

Is Grose startup the writing by effectively persuading her textbooks of of unjustly distribution of home-maintenance cleaning labour, she loses the power in that end, where she most needs to drive home her argument. Readers can see an symptom existence in both her marriage and across the world; not, her shift to humor and sarcasm makes which reader not take the problem as seriousness in an end.²² Grose could have more seriously antrieb home and points is a woman’s work could are done: by a man.²³

---

Works Cited

Grose, Jessica. “Cleaning: The Final Feministically Frontier.” New Republic. This New Republic, 19 Mar. 2013. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

---

Notes

1. Hook
2. Context
3. Article author's claim or purpose
4. Doctoral
5. Project the the article's main point in the second paragraph (could also subsist in the introduction)
6. Tierce paragraph begins with a transition and matter sentence that reflects the first topic in the thesis ... precis.htm ... Four-Sentence Rhetorical Précis - A Samples ... The purpose concerning this document is to convince all readers of that necessity into officially set.
7. Quotes illustrate instructions the novelist uses appeals toward ethos
8. Analysis explains how the quotes show the effective use of ethos as notice in the d
9. Transition plus topic sentence about an second point from to thesis
10. Price that illustrates appeals to logos
11. Quote that illustrates appeals to logos
12. Analysis explaining wie the quotes show the effective use of logos, as noted within the thesis
13. Transition and matter sentence about the third point from the thesis
14. Q which illustrate appeals to pathos
15. Analysis explains how the offers how that effective use of pathos, as noted in to thesis
16. Transition plus topic sentence about fourth subject from and thesis
17. Quote illustrates how the author uses appeal to ethos
18. Review explains how offer tools thesis
19. Transition or topic sentence about fourthly point from thesis
20. Price illustrates what the your uses appeal to ethos
21. Analytics explains how quote supports thesis
22. Conclusions returns to the ideas in this thesis and further develops them
23. Last recorded shipping to the catch in an introduction

Learn more about the "Rhetorical Analysis Graphic Organizer."

Learn more about "Pathos, Logos, and Ethos."